Advice topics from Wayne and Tamara Mitchell's newspaper advice column Direct Answers.
Direct Answers from Wayne and Tamara Logo
   Home      Articles      All Advice Topics     Write A Letter                                                                                Editors & Publishers     Webmasters     Resources
 

Alcoholism Advice


Alcoholism

This section includes a selection of questions and answers from letters, as well as remarks from Wayne & Tamara on "Alcoholism and Child Abuse."

     Problems With An Alcoholic

     Adult Children of Alcoholics (ACoA)

 

Alcoholism And Child Abuse

A long term study of alcohol abuse found that over 75% of alcohol dependent people never get treatment.  Of those who do get treatment, the average wait before beginning is 8-10 years.  As Bridget Grant, the lead author of the study, said, “That 10 years can be devastating.” 

If we couple that with the information we know about childhood—our ability to form relationships with others is closely linked to childhood experience—the conclusion is obvious.  If possible, the non-alcoholic spouse with children needs either to remove the alcoholic from the home, or to remove themselves and the children from the home.

The effects on children of living with an alcoholic parent are well known.  These include depression, inability to form close relationships, relentless self-criticism, inability to complete projects, and constant approval seeking.  Children growing up in a household with an alcoholic are damaged children.

If you drive drunk, you can end up in jail.  If you drop your children off with a drunk babysitter, the state may take your children away from you.  But if you keep a child in a home with a drunk for 3,000 or 4,000 or 5,000 days in a row, there is no legal penalty, though the effects are far worse.

For years alcohol abuse has been addressed as if there are two principal areas: the alcoholic and the adult child of an alcoholic (ACoA).  This allowed people to pretend that being an ACoA, or adult child of an alcoholic, was something adults caught, like the flu.

It is not. 

Adult children of alcoholics are adults who were systematically abused in childhood by living with a drunk. 

When children are forced to share their home with a drunk, we need to call what is going on by its proper name: child abuse.  The long-term negative effects on these children are profound.  The children grow up believing they are powerless to effect change.  They grow up with a fear, anxiety, and dread they cannot shed. 

It is neither admirable nor moral to trap a person in someone else’s behavior.  The spouse of a thief doesn’t have to say, I am trapped in thievery.  That logic is wacky.  It is a defense of the thief. 

In the same way, the spouse and children of a drunk don’t have to say, I am trapped by alcoholism.  That logic is also wacky.  Why?  Because it is a defense of a drunk whose behavior may never change.  It is a defense of child abuse.

Al-Anon, the organization for family and friends of alcoholics has 12 steps which parallel the 12 steps of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA).  The first of Al-Anon’s 12 steps is, “We admit we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become unmanageable.” 

That is absolutely not true.  The family and friends of alcoholics do have power.  They are free to say, “I am done with the effects of alcoholism in my life.  I’m moving on.” 

Raising children in alcoholic homes creates more damaged people, and it encourages more people to be enablers.  

Bridget Grant is correct in saying the 10 years before getting treatment for alcoholism can be devastating, but that barely touches the surface.  It will almost surely be many more years before the alcoholic stops drinking and stops acting like an alcoholic.  Indeed, that day may never come.

 And, of course, 75% of alcoholics never get treatment.

 

Sources:

Bridget F. Grant and others, “Prevalence, Disability, and Comorbidity of DSM-IV Alcohol Abuse and Dependence in the United States.”  Archives of General Psychiatry, July 2007.

Steven Reinberg, “Third of Americans Have Alcohol Problem at Some Point.”  Washington Post, July 2, 2007.

Janet G. Woititz, The Complete ACOA Sourcebook.  Health Communications, Inc,  2002.

 

© 1996-2014 Wayne & Tamara Mitchell
Privacy Policy / Terms of Service


Share










  

Adult Children of Alcoholics

    It doesn’t matter whether you think
  alcoholism is a disease, a moral
  failing, a chemical addiction, or the
  aftereffect of a lousy childhood.  The
  prognosis for successfully living with
  an alcoholic is poor.  If children are
  present, the consequences are dire.

    Human development follows a
  predictable pattern.  To develop their
  own brain, children need to be around
  mature brains--brains working from
  reality, brains meeting challenges and
  facing facts.  Observing those brains
  and patterning themselves after them,
  give children what they need to
  master life.

    Child abuse is the term which most
  accurately describes what children
  in an alcoholic home endure.